Opposition for The NHGRA Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words

Opposition for The NHGRA - Research Paper Example It discloses that the Native Hawaiians have been conferred with the right to reorganize their local governing entity that could work for their common welfare (Aleksandra, p1). The bill has been regarded a controversial legislation that appears to be a center point for hot debates for last years. Most of the Republicans voted against the bill including the Republican governor Linda Lingle expressed the reservations against the bill. Lingle pointed out that there are many unbelievable and impractical amendments included in the law. Two congressmen Doc Hastings and Tom McClintock also opposed the bill and registered their opposition to the passing of the amendment to NGHRA (Duncan, p4). The opponents of the bill took the stance that they do not regard Congress as authority to reorganize people of different ethnicities and races into different sovereign nations especially when the community has no history of separate self-governance. There is an important point raised by the opposing congressmen that the creation of such independent entity would not be in long-term favor of the country because it will set an example for the other ethnic groups and nations and will encourage them to demand similar treatment. They opposed the bill also because it establishes a government on a racial basis (Joshua, p1). The congressmen have expressed their reservations regarding the amendments of the bill as they have observed several flaws in the bill. They also claim that it is a racist bill that poses serious threats to Americans as well as Hawaiians because it takes away the property rights from the Hawaiians and their legal heirs and singles out them on the basis of their origin. It has been demonstrated that the Hawaiian government will have complete sovereignty including ordinary tort and contract lawsuit but this move is not in favor of the people of Hawaii. The bill divides the people of a nation on the basis of their race and accord and bestows different rights.